Quantcast
Channel: The Express Tribune
Viewing all 26 articles
Browse latest View live

19 girls, one car: I was one of them!

$
0
0

Challenges make you discover things about yourself that you never really knew. They are what make you go beyond the norm. The same applies to what my team and I achieved on the December 15, 2010 when we successfully set a new Guinness World Record by fitting into a Standard two-seater Daimler Benz Production Smart Car. Doing something smart with my smart car I realized that I possess a Smart Car which is a rarity - at least in Pakistan. In fact whenever I took it out on a drive I was followed by inquisitive admirers. While browsing newspaper headlines in my living room, I came across a story on the world’s largest cake. This story aroused my curiosity and soon enough I started searching on the internet to see what records were set by my car. After a quick search on Google, I came across a video of 18 people from Australia crammed into a smart car. This was inspirational and I started working on it. Of course initially whoever heard of it, laughed it off, but I was resolute -I knew something could be done. I started contacting my friends and convinced my parents that something like this could be attempted. Seeing my determination, my parents, Saleem Yousuf and Shereen Saleem, who believed thoroughly in my conviction agreed to help me. Apart from my parents, my brother, Sharam Saleem and both my uncles Dr Mirza Ikhtiar Baig and Ishtiaq Baig supported me and encouraged me throughout my journey. Now there was no looking back. Preparing for our challenge After encountering certain teething problems, we were at it. I contacted the officials of the Guinness Book of World Records, and collected the necessary data. With their permission to carry out the record breaking attempt, my team and I started the drills night and day. From the beginning all their requirements were kept in mind including media coverage, height, video footage and a credible jury. Initially, collecting girls that met the standard requirement for the feat was a challenge itself. Furthermore the examination season posed problems to assembling all of them together. Yet with gaps and glitches, we continued. At one time it seemed that we could not go beyond 12 girls! Slowly we increased the number. We actually had to watch very closely - from hairdos to diets. My mom took the responsibility of not only being the chaperone but also taking care of the details like providing us with deodorants to control body odour and making sure that all the girls were properly showered and had clean hair! It was fun but the challenge was becoming more and more daunting. Here I would say that without the complete cooperation of my team this would have been impossible. We wanted to show the world that the Pakistani youth, especially the girls, can do what no one else in the world can - and so we did! Although it was a novel idea - it was challenging. And challenges are what Pakistani youth must think of taking up. My parents, family members, teachers and friends are proud of my team and I. But it’s not my victory; it’s the victory of our nation. I am happy that my team and I have set this new world record for Pakistan. We are proud Pakistanis today and with a world record attempt in my folio, I hope to conquer the world after I get a degree from a prestigious international university! Long Live Pakistan! The 19 participants-without whom this would have been impossible:

Muneezeh Jamal Sana Javed Sarah Ahmad Rabbya Kamran Rida Ashraf Eman Samir Neha Sadruddin Sana Currimbhoy Zoya Currimbhoy Zashanne Malik Fatima Ismail Tanya Pabani Sana Ghazi Nadia Khan Anum Afridi Dania Fayyaz Hala Faruqi Hafsa Naveed Alina Akram


Revelry for relief: Fiddling while Sindh sinks

$
0
0

The sensitivity of young people today should ideally never be gauged by the first question that comes to their minds when a bomb goes off in Karachi: Will there be school tomorrow? Instead, Karachi’s generation-next should be assessed on how much hard work, effort and time its members put into relief camps and charity distribution, placard holding and general running around they did in an effort to contribute to alleviating the pain of the people hit by the flooding this summer. There was a definite perception that young privileged girls and boys just live in their bubble on that side of the bridge and don’t really care about the other humans they share a country with. But if the flood relief efforts are anything to go by, let alone the home schools and separate year-round efforts, a different picture emerges. Some of the good work included personal charity drives, pitching tents at much-visited spots such as Agha’s Supermarket’s parking lot or outside the Forum to urge people to donate, working through school networks to send out appeals for water, blankets, toys, books, food, medicines. Others spent school hours packing the material, or badgering their factory-owning fathers to arrange trucks to be dispatched to the villages. The older ones even jumped onto the trucks, braved looting and the unchartered territory and headed into the swimming fields of Sindh. For others, there was another ingenious way to try and solve other people’s problems. So what if you can’t make it up to Tori Bund and hand out Peditral and ORS to diarrhoea-cramped survivors? You could instead attend a masked charity ball! But first tickets needed to be sold, somehow, at this extraordinarily difficult time. “So, who’s coming?” I ask. The ticket-seller replies in an attempt to sound casual, “The usual schools.” A list is produced. “Wait a second,” I quickly scan it. “Why is this school included? Oi! Come back here. Why are these melas on the list?” Someone else joins the conversation. “Do we have to pay?” “Oh right, yes,” responds the ticket-seller. “Only RsX,000. But please do come, OK? Did you get the Facebook notification?” [It was a non-school, completely private masquerade ball] “Yeah, I did see that. But?” “Limited tickets till Friday only. Then, I’ll be super busy figuring out the masks and all. But I could make an exception for you.” A ticket is flapped in my face. “So, it’s a yes?” I hesitate for a second too long to answer. A sanctimonious well-worn phrase is trotted out for special effect: “But, it’s for charity!” That hurt, as did the arched eyebrows and innocent wide-eyed questioning by the ticket seller. What kind of person are you? You can’t buy a ticket for charity? My excuses don’t stand a chance. My parents already gave X amount of rupees to the prime minister’s relief fund. Or, did you know how expensive goats were this Eid? Anything to cover up the fact that I didn’t own a ‘gown’ or a ‘masque’ or simply, didn’t think it was appropriate given the scale of the devastation. “Honestly,” cajoles the ticket-seller, reading my mind. “You could come in a dhoti even. Forget gowns. Come in your school uniform if you have to! OK. No, wait. I take that back. That would be extremely embarrassing if you did.” Someone else pipes up helpfully to join the attempt to persuade me to fork over the rather strange amount of cash. “My mum, khala AND phuppee will be there. How much parental supervision do you need?” When I murmur that my close friends aren’t planning on attending a ball, the ticket-seller reacts with chagrin and indignation. “What am I to you?” The sidekick butts in. “We’ve hired a contingent of security forces, no need for your mum to go all emo.” Let me get this straight. They’re “hiring” a security contingent to guard a party while they simultaneously lament the lack of security everywhere else? But it didn’t matter. I wasn’t going. Later, I was showed pictures of the party, suits and long, covered gowns milling about with little glasses of Coke. It was all rather tame. And yet, the organisers not only broke even, they managed to set aside a decent ‘profit’ that was sent through various NGOs to the flood survivors just in time for Eid. I’m still a little divided over the phenomenon of revelry for relief. Is it akin to fiddling while Rome burns or is it better to do something, anything rather than not play at all?


Dear Google, you have failed me!

$
0
0

Dear Google, It pains me immensely to say this but you have let me down in my utmost time of need. I always thought there was not a question in this world that would return unanswered from your domain. I always relied on you for the smallest of queries, recommendations and confirmations, and I must admit that it had been so far, so good. Be it a school research assignment on Alaska, finding some economic or cricket statistics, or checking online for symptoms that my kid would be down with, or even looking up the answer to some radio contest question, you were my hero! My savior! My best-est, most reliable resource. Until last week! Yes, just last week, all I googled was these four words:

"Karachi Grammar Test Preparation".
You see, this year, my second-grader becomes eligible for the second time out of the four times-in-a-lifetime opportunity of sitting the admission test for the most prestigious school of Karachi. And unlike the aspiring parents of most seven-year-olds who have been sending their offspring for very strenuous and very very expensive tuitions for the entire year, we decided only last week that we wanted our daughter to sit the entrance test. Part of that decision came from faith in you, Google! I trusted you to help me enough to prepare my daughter in these 17 days. But all that you returned in response to my search was the Karachi Grammar School (KGS) website link, a Wikipedia link , and a few news articles from past years lamenting about the plight of aspiring parents…that's it! No guidance absolutely on what the kids get tested on. No past papers or info on the syllabi! How, Google, how? How is it that you have the answer to the weirdest questions in the world, and yet fail to provide me with any clue regarding something that is the nexus of the universe of some 2000 odd sets of parents right now?? How is it possible that of such 2000 odd different sets of parents that go through this ordeal every year, none have bothered to log their activity or experience on cyberspace, even though every detail of their lives such as their meals and the last movie watched recorded by the minutes? So Google, thanks to your cold shoulder, the only ammunition that I am left with is hearsay! Hearsay about what the kids are doing at these rigorous test preparation classes by some Mrs Virjee and Mrs Mukaty. Hearsay, about what was asked in previous year's test. Hearsay, that the kids sitting the exam for Grade III will be tested from the curriculum of Grade III and not Grade II. Nothing confirmed, all muddled and hazy. All these unfounded reports and advice have overwhelmed me! They have overwhelmed me in the exact same way as they did four years ago, when I was told that my then three-year-old was expected to write her full name in the entrance test for kindergarten at KGS. To date, I have never found out if she was actually asked to do that or not. And Google, again, I am still searching for an answer from you. But Google, I am hoping for this time to be different. Why? Because my daughter will certainly be able to fill me in on the content of this exam after she sits for it. So, regardless of the outcome of her exam, I am planning to log this information on the web for the benefit of aspiring parents in future years. And I certainly hope that more parents will start to think like me. So next time, perhaps you will not let another parent down, Google! Sincerely, A searcher This post was originally published here.

The rat race of KGS admissions

$
0
0

Mrs A remembers it as 'the most horrible week of my life.' She cried frequently; she had trouble sleeping at night; she had to leave a party early because she felt like she 'couldn't breathe'. And too many of her hours were filled with 'whys'; why did this happen to her? Why? A child stricken with life-threatening illness? The collapse of the family business? The death of a beloved parent?  No, the darkest week of Mrs A’s life came two weeks ago when her daughter was rejected admission in the nursery at Karachi Grammar School (KGS). It’s hard to imagine writing such a sentence as anything other than a joke, but for well-heeled parents across Karachi, the elite like Mrs A; the ambitious, the academically inclined and the socially well connected, nursery is intensely serious business. Between growing populations and an increasingly competitive job market, getting your child into one of the city’s most prestigious private schools has become a gruelling, multi-year competition, with its own rules, code language, and intrigue. It’s a mean competition too - one that can turn sensible, mannerly, child-loving parents and educators into hard, calculating, and paranoid operators. (Almost everyone interviewed for this article insisted that she not be quoted by name and that all identifying characteristics be disguised.) That applying to nursery should become such cut-throat business is doubtless a joke to those not in it - “yet”, said one parent darkly - or with children already past that age. However, the pint-size contestants of this game are merely the most striking example of a profound change in sentiments about early childhood, achievement, status and what it means to be successful in Karachi. Karachi’s greatest school: Do you have ‘it’? The opinions you will hear about Karachi Grammar School are as varied as the students who attend it. Most people, some grudgingly, will admit that the teachers are by and large seasoned educators, the nursery program one of the best in the country and the A' Level graduates, the highest scoring, frequently of world-wide fame. And with very few exceptions, everyone will also concede that KGS has one more notable quality that holds it aloft year after year; age. The red brick building is as integral a part of Karachi architecture as anything else. It holds the mystique of privilege that is hard to manufacture anew and that continues to radiate the old-money glamour that makes even the nouveau-riche of Karachi aspire to some post-Colonial remnants of English polish. The colour of students’ uniforms, the prefectorial gowns, the historical connotations of the many, many success stories that are KGS alumni, has given the institution an affiliation to triumphant achievement hard to match and understandably, in a country full of suffering, one that parents are desperate for their children to at least be near to. Estimates for the number of nursery applications the school receives each year varies wildly, depending on how hysterical the parent being questioned is feeling at that point. Some put the figure at about 800, while others swear it’s closer to 2,000. The selected candidates amount to 100 usually and so the odds are similar to some of the top universities in the world. Add to this the number of children of alumni and siblings of current students, both of whom get preferential treatment in admissions, and what you have left is only a handful of openings for the general populace. However, though no one likes to talk about it, there is more at work here than increased demand and low supply. The almost Darwinian struggle for a KGS nursery spot is also evidence of the triumph of the cognitive elitism that has swamped the upper middle class of this country. The obsession with academics has been a prominent part of Pakistan for a while now (perhaps evidenced by the star status handed to established teachers and tutors). To get your child into KGS is to confirm that he is one of the cognitive elect. As a result, the school becomes part of a product orientation - measurable success: where you go to college, what kind of job you have, how you dress, how well you speak English. In short, who you are in Karachi's society. Making things more loaded for today’s parents is that other sources of identity and status have faded in significance. One mother confided:

I know plenty of women who would rather die than say their child got rejected from Grammar It’s effectively admitting you don’t have ‘it’, whatever ‘it’ might be.
In short, your child’s perceived brain power and social polish says a lot about who you are in Karachi! Race to the top: Who says what’s fair? The result is an admissions process that is not for the tender-hearted. The parents and the child are evaluated. The parents have their own interview which includes a pleasant but thorough examination of the family culture, the professional lives of both mother and father and the manifestation of their relationship to their child. And then, it’s the child’s turn. And, just how do admissions directors measure up the four-year-old? Through a test, though no one dares refer to it as a test. It’s euphemistically referred to as an “interview” where the child is taken to a separate room where two or three adults will be watching as various questions and tasks are placed before him. No parent interviewed for this article could comprehensively articulate about the test. One mother says laughingly:
Keep in mind, we’re relying on a bunch of four year olds to tell us what went on in there.
The irony that those same four year olds, who are too young to be trusted when it comes to accurately describing what just happened in the room, are the same ones expected to perform (willingly, intelligently, graciously) on demand to total strangers is not lost on her. Some children have described basic pre-school tasks such as stacking blocks, separating objects by color and identifying farm animals. There are flash cards and a little bit of art. Other candidates have mentioned physical activity areas and being asked to navigate structures similar to those found in indoor playgrounds. Sounds simple enough at this point, doesn’t it? Except of course, as with any situation where passions are running high, there are also the stories which seem to be the stuff of urban legends. That’s where it gets tricky and the parents begin to hyperventilate.
My son was asked to identify a polar bear and a penguin! That’s a bit much don’t you think? Lucky for us, we’ve just moved from Canada so he’s familiar with winter animals, thanks to all the Christmas advertisements he’s seen on television. But, how is this a fair question for Pakistani kids? My daughter was practically grilled on what kind of time her dad spends with her. How many hours per week, what do they do together? Okay, so he travels a lot for work but is her confusion over this question a fair assessment of how happy and stable our family is? And how exactly is this relevant for a child’s nursery education?
A third parent questions the setup of the interview itself:
Why should a kid, a smart kid, but maybe with a bit of social anxiety, want to perform for total strangers all of a sudden? How is this a fair indication of their intelligence?
'Fair' - the word that comes up frequently. It leads to much greater questions about the validity and practicality of the approach that private schools must take due to space and time limitations. No more so than when it comes to the well-known philosophy KGS has of giving preferential treatment to the offspring of their alumnus when it comes to admissions. This has led to generations upon generations of KGS graduates coming from the same families - a community within a community. Those not in the ‘in’, insist on the inherent injustice of this. Others, especially those part of the familial legacy say, this is common practice all over the world. Alma mater pride is built by these ideas, and as one Grammarian says:
You don’t see me complaining when Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) employees' family members get discounts. It gives a sense of community which feels good and I suspect most people would like to be part of it which is why they lash out so badly when they don’t get in.
“Not your parents’ nursery!”: Battling for a spot Because no one really knows what happens in the entrance test for Karachi Grammar School’s nursery admissions, the idea seems to be to prepare for everything. Web forums are littered with pleas:
Does anyone know anything about the KGS entrance tests? Please help. Desperate!
There was a time, not that long ago, when few parents attempted to prepare their four year olds for nursery admission tests. But then a few more began to do it, and then more, and then suddenly, normal-seeming people with normal-seeming values began doing it too, and an arms-race mentality kicked in. Responding to parents’ anxieties and fears, some of the fancier pre-schools began subtly prepping their students and private tuition flourished. When I asked a mother from Defence if she knew of any children being tutored for the Grammar test, she said no — before proceeding to describe how she had placed her own child in a program “to develop her fine motor skills.” When I asked another mother to share the name of the educational videos she had been raving about (brought from London for a cool 1,200 pounds), the woman refused:
It is a wonderful DVD set, but this is my find. I don’t want to share it, otherwise everyone will just copy me.
Actually, the unspoken rule seems to be that you never allow anyone to know your child is being tutored or prepped in any way. This is partly because parents want their child to seem effortlessly brilliant, a studied carelessness or sprezzatura for the educated elites. One lady who regularly advertises her services for admissions in to KGS, Bayview, Froebels and Foundation Public School says:
People are quite secretive about hiring me. Many parents go into full battle mode over the interview/test. Families hire tutors and that’s where I come in. It’s my job to prep the child with as similar a test as the school itself.
She shows me her workbooks and flips it open to the “Vocabulary” section.
Any vocabulary the child needs, is in this book, whether it’s to complete picture analogies or understand questions that are asked of them.
When she works with a student, she says with a weary sigh, “the primary challenge is keeping their attention.” With a three-and-a-half year old at home, her statement is just a reminder of something I already know: Four year olds, no matter how smart and delightful they may be, have obvious limits as test takers. Many, especially boys, can’t sit still; others can’t concentrate for that long, choosing at some catastrophic point to crawl under their desks and give up. Nor is the context in which these tests are administered exactly relaxing for young children. The tutor lady explained to me:
To be fair, KGS does give three chances for the child to try and come inside but it’s still pretty daunting, wouldn't you agree? But then school itself is just so much harder now. It’s certainly not the nursery of our parents’ youth!
In addition, on the part of the parents themselves, a certain polish and je ne sais quoi are a must. No small measure of the enormous anxiety among today’s prospective KGS nursery parents arises out of the recognition that this, the elitest of private schools retains a modicum of class snobbery. To make oneself of that class, prospective parents have to play their cards right and have that odd combination of old-world manners mixed with knowledge-economy hustling and self-promotion that characterises the winners of this game.
"You should be interested but not overly eager. You must be well-dressed but no overkilling the designer wardrobe. Your English should be flawless but fake accents are a no-no. You should be well-prepared but not seem hyper and paranoid,"
This is how one mother tried to helpfully explain what the ‘right’ type of message needs to come across from the parents during their interview. Add to this, the lore that circulates amongst parental circles of how other parents prepared, and you have the ingredients of a highly anxious populace.
She wore diamonds! He wore Armani! They bought a play structure identical to the one used in the test so their kid could practice! She and her husband memorized their answers using cue cards! They sent a thank you gift basket afterwards!
School administrators roll their eyes at all of this, and it’s clear that there’s no one correct sentence, outfit, or behaviour that will seal the deal. Of course, I couldn’t say this with a guarantee because KGS administration famously doesn't give interviews. Couple that with the fact that admission results are revealed at midnight on a Friday - depending on which side of the fence you’re on, you see either a savvy public relations ploy designed for maximum intrigue or a mature and necessary policy to best avoid the hysteria both before and after results are announced. How many diamonds does it take to get in? No matter how much energy parents put into branding their child-products, what happens is that achievement threatens to become the only means by which they know and judge their children. When parents receive less-than-acceptable results from the KGS process, the doubt begins to gnaw.
My child is bright and polished and she went to the best preschool in town. My husband and I are successful entrepreneurs and well connected. And now I am spending my nights wondering, 'Should I have gotten tutoring?'
A friend recalls one mother saying who called after her “disastrous rejection”, crying:
Is something wrong with me? Is something wrong with my son?
One mother puzzled over the rejection of her son remarked:
My sister’s son got in. And everything between her application and ours was identical. Our boys are practically twins in habits and personality. Did I do something wrong? Did he freeze? Was there some sort of performance anxiety at play?
Then she paused in a way that made my heart tug as a fellow mother. She added:
I can’t believe I am saying this about my four-year-old
But then in the KGS world, people seem to be saying - and doing - all sorts of things about four year olds that they’ve never said and done before. Still, there are resisters. A mother of two boys, both of who, interestingly, go to KGS says:
It nags at me that we live in this mad, mad world. These are kids! Why are we rushing them in to some sort of power-life? My husband and I agonised over it; we wanted to protect them from the craziness. We eventually decided we’d go for the admissions but it wouldn’t matter to us either way if they got in or not.
Another disgusted mother told me that she refused to go down that route at all:
Some people snidely suggest I am afraid my daughter wouldn’t get in, so that’s why I’m not trying. And for a minute, I did think ‘I'm a bad mother, I am not giving her all the advantages that a KGS student would get. But then I am like, that’s just insane. She’s going to be in nursery. She’s only three!
Which is what I said, again and again, about my own son as I researched and interviewed for this article. “He’s only three!” I would exclaim every time someone asked me if I wasn’t worried that the publishing of this article would damn forever his chances of a spot in KGS. And then I would look at my son and wonder: Am I doing him a disservice? Never mind the fact that I am actually not criticising the school anyways. One part of me is convinced he would never get in, so any of my published views on the subject would hardly matter. It would seem that what is essential for myself and the Mrs As of Karachi to grasp is that, especially in today’s world, there are many kinds of stories imaginable. A child goes to some Urdu-medium school in an unknown village, but discovers his talent during A' Levels and ends up at Oxford doing a PhD in applied statistics. His rich cousin, goes to Grammar and makes it to Harvard too, but then wanting to spend more time with family, takes a relaxed editing job at a local newspaper. The girl who was a B student at an army school launched a successful beauty parlour business. The boy who got rejected from KGS and went to St. Patrick's instead went on to become the CEO of the biggest bank in the country. And that’s the tricky thing to remember about the wild ride of this life. It can be hard to guess the end from the beginning. But at the same time, as one KGS teacher (off the record, naturally) said:
Look, the school is great, no doubt about it. But the gloriously shiny beacon of all that is excellent and true, this whole larger than life image it’s been given? That’s the parents doing. Not the school-walay. And certainly not the kids. I mean when was the last time you saw a four-year-old staring bereft at his little Transformers figure because he didn’t make the cut at an academic institution? On the other hand, when you see the star-studded alumnus and you hear of their achievements and you see how people sit up just a little bit straighter and pay you a little bit more respect when they hear your kid is a Grammarian, that’s a nod to something, isn't it? So can you blame the parents for wanting that for their child?
She has, it would seem, a point. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- [poll id="150"]

‘Faiz is a hat?’

$
0
0

For those who do not know (and that number is growing) November 20 is the death anniversary of one of Urdu’s great intellectuals and poets, Faiz Ahmad Faiz. Sadly, the man and his body of work have become increasingly irrelevant for many Pakistanis, including myself. Conversation in the newsroom

Me (upon spotting the story on a local news site): “Guys, today is the death anniversary of Faiz – are we covering it?” (Clueless) subeditor: “Isn’t Faiz a hat?”
Yes, Fez is a hat. And yes, Faiz has been reduced to token mentions in the print media or online (“Today is Faiz’ birth or death anniversary – please read this copy-paste history on him from Wikipedia”), even fewer mentions on TV, and the odd Facebook share with some out-of-context stand-alone prose, generally being used to further the agenda of the sharer. This is truly a sad state of affairs, and what’s worse is that I am part of the problem. I am completely ill-informed thanks to my education at Karachi Grammar School which never touched upon Faiz (though I assume he could/should be relevant to an O Level audience). My ‘western style’ upbringing means no encounters with Faiz at home. Even though my mother is well-versed and well-read when it comes to Faiz and Urdu literature, she never bothered to share any of that with me, reasons unknown. We have volumes of Faiz, but they sit on dusty shelves doing nothing for no one. I once tried to find good, free translations online, but the search left me weary. I found more hats than prose. At my university abroad, Faiz had no place. At my jobs at Geo, Dawn and now at Express, his relevance has been next to none, or muted (see above description of putting together news on Faiz’ anniversaries). I have no idea where Faiz is, and neither do the people I live and hang out with. I know this is a monumental loss because people tell me it is, but when I ask them about Faiz, they tend to know more about the hat than the man and his work. Unfortunately, this loss of Faiz is not just among the burger bachas I know - it extends from my uneducated driver all the way up to senior staff at news organisations. The loss of Faiz is real, what it will mean for us...I really do not know. Read more by Jahanzaib here or follow him on Twitter @jhaque_

Terror on Facebook ‘Confession’ pages, from KGS to CAS

$
0
0

Rehtaeh Parsons was just 17. What could lead a 17-year-old to such a state that ending her life appeared to be the only way out of her misery? Cyber bullying, it appears. This case bears stark similarities to that of Amanda Todd’s – another teenager who took her own life early in October last year due to severe bullying over the internet. Both girls suffered from acute depression due to the fact that nasty rumours and compromising pictures of the two had been making rounds online. Teenagers can be cruel and intolerant. They can cripple your self-confidence to the point where you feel as though no matter what you do in life or how you do it, nobody will ever allow you to be you or love you for whom you are. I was, indeed, saddened when I heard of both these cases. When I was a teenager, cyber bullying wasn’t really a threat to our age group as the internet had only just started to gather momentum. Our interactions were limited to MSN conversations and, at most, exchanges via Orkut. However, the cyber space has changed and children in this digital age know how to use a keyboard better than a pen. I shouldn’t, thus, have been surprised when I stumbled across various Facebook Confession pages, but I just couldn’t contain my horror. To all those who believe that Pakistan's conservative society could prevent incidents of bullying - akin to those suffered by Amanda Todd and Rehtaeh Parsons – from occurring here, I hate to burst your bubble. It seems as though shows like Gossip Girl have left a notable imprint on youth here and they are not afraid to publish nasty rumours about their peers to socially annihilate them. These pages have sprouted all across Pakistan and are run by teenagers who attend various schools here. Just type the name of the school followed by the word “confessions” in your Facebook search box and we will see a plethora of pages pop up. Once you view the content here, you will find that Pakistani teenagers are no angels. They are no less cruel than their Canadian counterparts and have mastered the art of cyber bullying with various Facebook pages made for their respective schools.

Warning: Graphic content ahead
I skimmed through some of these pages to see the sort of entries students were posting about each other. Aside from overly sexualized content, what I found - characteristic to typical bullying - was that specific students were targeted for being different. Personal remarks were made based on appearances – if you are fat, you will get a snarky remark which shares your full name and says that you just cannot like a girl because you are fat and thereby completely unworthy. If you have a limited wardrobe, you are held to the same standard of contempt: What was especially appalling was the sheer number of entries that propagated that certain students were homosexual. In a country where homosexuality is highly taboo, it sent shivers down my spine to see full names of students here and claims that they are gay or lesbian. Please do not get me wrong, these comments were not meant in good humour or jest. They were placed deliberately to ostracise and target certain students. What I don’t think these teenagers think of is the repercussions outside of school that such posts could have. A family member or any relative could stumble across the full name of their kin (this has happened) and may read many alleging that this boy is ‘gay’. This can lead to devastating consequences. If the child’s family is fanatical, he could be beaten and even killed by his family. Let us not pretend that this is a far cry from the truth. As for social consequences, at a time and age where all you want to do is to fit in, comments like so can be devastating to one's self-esteem. I have no doubt that these students are mocked and avoided by the entire school based on these posts; that’s where cyber bullying can be so much more dangerous than just regular bullying. The reach these posts have is unlimited; anybody can see them. Hence, not only can the entire school read that a certain girl has terrible body odour, any person can log on to this page and read the same, much like I did. This reach can make a child a target in many circles. If say, this girl or boy decides to leave this particular school where he or she is being bullied and hope for a fresh start - much like Amanda Todd - it is virtually impossible because anyone can access the malicious posts and thus, there can be no fresh start. With posts such as the above, it is clear that these teens will stop at nothing. How far they will they go to shun and snub their peers and spell out that they are unwanted and unaccepted is a topic I do not even want to contemplate. What I do know for certain is that if this continues, it is only a matter of time before we hear of a Pakistani Rehtaeh Parsons and Amanda Todd, and that will be a sad day indeed. It is my request, thus, to all parents to teach your child the value of tolerance and acceptance. Inculcate in them to be kind to those who are different and help them to understand the damage that can be caused by hate speech. I further beseech all schools to keep a stricter eye on their students. In the cyber age, duties of teachers extend beyond just the classroom. Please keep checks on the cyber space to see if your students are being bullied. Report these pages for they use the official name of your school. You will be held accountable if disaster occurs and you could have an innocent child’s blood on your hands. Please, put an end to these crude pages and posts. List of some of the pages: KGS Gossip World    KGS Confessions and crushes   FPS OLDC Confessions    Bayview high crushes and confessions    CAS Confessions   BVA Confessions  You can take action by reporting pages on Facebook. Read more by Zahra here or follow her on Twitter @ZahraPeer

KGS admission blues and the pursuit of (academic) happiness

$
0
0

Saturday, March 16, 2013 was probably one of the few very anticipated days in the academic calendar. For many, it was undoubtedly a defining moment for their kids. Yes, it was the day when one of the most prestigious schools in Karachi held its admission test for entry into class three. Success would mean victory, triumph and a sense of academic achievement par excellence. Failure would spell doom, despair, depression and a social stigma - in other words - for some nothing short of a calamity. The so called pursuit of academic excellence, if that is what we are after, comes with a heavy price – mentally, physically and monetarily. Initial preparation starts with finding a tutor who has apparently broken the code - they know what exactly to teach, how to teach it and how to make your kids the super stars that they are not. So the hunt starts one year earlier and it’s not easy. You sometimes need to pull a few strings, have some references and only then are the experts willing to take your child. One actually pre-screens to assess if the child has the potential to be tutored. The monthly charges can vary from anything between Rs12, 000 up to Rs20, 000. A group may consist of five to ten kids and there may be three to four groups ranging from class three to ten. Not too difficult to do the calculations of how much tax free income this accounts for. The anxiety levels start to increase a few weeks before the test. That’s when the appointment slips are made available and you just cannot afford to relax on that window of opportunity that exists for only 90 minutes in the morning. In this day and age when technology has transformed the world, you are still required to queue as early as 6am, depending on how unsure you are of missing the bus. How different could boot camp have been, I wonder. Clearing the first hurdle is the precursor to the interview for your child and both parents. One must be on their best behaviour and not forget the well-rehearsed answers they have memorised like a script for a play. The three to four minute interview is surely good enough to assess the child’s potential or lack thereof. A peculiar question is asked - whether the child has had any extra tutoring. I wonder if that influences the outcome because surprisingly, those kids with expert help mostly do make the final cut. And then comes the test. Parents drop their kids off and wait anxiously for the three hours or so to pass. Notes are exchanged once the kids are out. There are frowns on the faces of some and smiles on others.

“This was such an easy test” a kid says with overflowing confidence.
Her parents are not too sure and try to hide their apprehension with a forced smile. Such are the pressures. Saturday, April 20, 2013 and the results are out! Facebook statuses are updated promptly and likes are obtained simultaneously. Congratulatory messages are sent as are consolation messages. The senses of victory or despondency become realities. Some talk of their lives being over and share a tearful story; others cannot get over the feeling of euphoria and jubilation. Every parent strives to give the best schooling to their child but I question the parameters that define a good school. It is important to understand how well a particular school is performing today rather than reflecting upon its glorious history and legacy as a benchmark of its current academic excellence. Prestigious schools may so be called but I fail to comprehend their standard of education when a large segment of the student body from junior section to senior section takes after school tuitions. If the faculty is good enough why is there a need for extra aid? If the students are good enough why do they need help? There are lesser known schools that have produced equally good if not better results and, charismatic and confident students. Aspirants to these schools do not invest thousands of rupees in preparatory classes because apparently, that is not a prerequisite. Yes, these students also attend tuitions but that may be acceptable as they are not meant to be the best. Mostly, such elite institutions’ stature has now become a reflection of their social acceptability and legacy rather than the quality of education they impart. Yet, everyone continues to be part of the rat race.

Five great reasons why I will vote for Bilawal Bhutto

$
0
0

Is Bilawal Bhutto Zardari running for the National Assembly? Is he not running for the National Assembly? Do we have to wait till 2018, or a few months? The media really needs to make up its mind…like me! I am all set to vote for the boy in red, black and green – and here are five excellent reasons why. 1. Line up all our current Members of the National Assembly (MNAs) and then take a good look. No seriously, do it right now. I’ve got a handy dandy random selection for you to peruse below! I shouldn’t have to argue my point too far – Bilawal Bhutto is at least five times hotter than our average law maker and ten times more approachable. Sure, all the haters can argue this point, but it’s still a fact. Are good looks and some level of relatability frivolous reasons to vote for someone? If they are, then damn, half my khaandan and friends voted for Imran Khan frivolously. 2. Bilawal is educated. Like, seriously educated – he went to Karachi Grammar School/Froebel’s and Oxford University. Yeah I don’t care how hard he partied in this time, I’m pretty sure some of that education seeped into him (also, partying is normal, just look at Imran, he turned out...okay?). Yeah I also don’t care about your “once a feudal, always a feudal” argument against him. I think it’s a pretty safe assumption that he’s heard this criticism, oh, a few thousand times in his life, and has assessed what he needs to do here. I think Bilawal is educated, and thinks more like me than most of our illustrious MNAs. In fact, if he only thinks like me 10% of the time, he will still share more similar views with me than the average MNA. 3. He is super amusing, and more importantly, pretty real on Twitter. His haters will, well, obviously hate on his flamboyant, sometimes naïve (sometimes insightful), sometimes out there... and okay fine, sometimes this: But I doubt the haters would deny that Bilawal’s updates are human, something most of our politicians lack. 4. Bilawal has two sisters, no brothers – that is, in my opinion, the ideal combination for a Pakistani male’s upbringing. I am banking on the fact that he will be just a tad bit more sensitive to issues that women face thanks to his sisters (not to mention his mom), and both Bakhtawar and Aseefa will keep him in line, perhaps ground him when the filth that is politics starts to corrupt him. For those who don’t know, Bilawal’s sisters are pretty damn cool! Yeah. I’m convinced. Call me a burger bachi with a corrupt western mindset or whatever - this is something I can get behind. 5. Bilawal is a multi-millionaire (billionaire?). He has it all. He could very well opt to stay out of politics and the mess that is Pakistan, but hey, he is stepping up and putting himself out there to face threats and the kind of vile criticism and hate the poor ET comment mods will probably have to delete all day from this post. Call it the Bhutto way. Call it enormous pressure on a boy unable to say no. Call it what you will, what I see is a guy who is knowingly ready to sacrifice himself for this mad country we call home. So if I get the chance, I will vote for Bilawal, and maybe you should too. Or you could do the Pakistani thing and start bashing the guy (and me too, why not) cause hey, that’s what we do best.



Karachi Grammar School admission blues: Do you have what it takes?

$
0
0

It is that time of the year again when parents of three-year-olds queue up breathlessly outside the most coveted red building in Pakistan, to get their wards admitted into this 150-odd years old institution thus, ensuring a ‘secure and bright future’ for their beloved offspring. Some of these little ones have been going to preparatory classes along with their preschools, filling their lives with more alphabets and numbers than any three-year-old should be subjected to. Every parent who saunters into this school is confident that his or her child is ‘the best’ and if Karachi Grammar School (KGS) lets them fall through the admission net they will be beating their proverbial chests in anguish for the rest of their existence. The child is made to attend an interview, along with the parents, and is then escorted inside for a short assessment session, while the parents wait outside. Whatever happens inside is anybody’s guess and you have to rely on the words of the little ones and that too if they decide to share the experience. But I know from experience that neither the interview nor the assessment comprises of any rocket science, like people tend to believe. It consists of just the basic stuff that any average child of that age attending any preschool worth its salt, knows or should know. Nobody knows what exactly goes on in those fifteen-odd minutes the child is inside since the auditorium in which the appraisal is conducted is guarded like Fort Knox. As for the interview, the questions asked are also very basic and trust me, they don’t care whether you drove to the school in your latest Audi or a 10-year-old beat-up Suzuki Mehran; whether you are wearing the latest Sania Maskatiya or a generic lawn shalwar kameez; whether there are multiple diamonds flashing on your fingers or you are wearing an imitation ring. In my opinion, what is important to them is how well-disciplined and smart your child is, how involved you are as parents and what kind of values you hold. And trust me, no matter how much you attempt to lie through your teeth about the time you spend with your child and how disciplined he or she is, the truth shows in your body language. No amount of holding hands, gushing with love for your child and spouse, and buttering up the head mistress can help your case if it is just a farce. My suggestion to all those aspiring to be KGS parents is to be yourself and avoid rubbing off your tension on your children by asking them to be someone they are not. The more anxious you will be, the more agitated they will become. And that will not help the admission process at all. Being part of the coveted KGS parent body does not simply mean preparing for a test; it is a conscious move to adapt to a certain lifestyle. If I have to say one thing about the parent body, it would be that they are extremely involved in their children’s school life – not only at the day-to-day homework level but also in being a part of everything that happens at school from the reading sessions to the bake sales, from the field trips to the sing songs, from the plays to the after-school clubs, from the sports activities to the Parent Teacher Meetings (PTM). These parents turn up in droves to donate blood at the annual blood camp and are ready to come out of their homes to protest against the illegal construction of a building next to the school. So, before coaching your child for the KGS admission test, ask yourself first,

“Do we have the ‘G-factor’?”

Does Aitchison give more importance to kinship than KGS?

$
0
0

Before we go on to tackle the issue of kinship and its importance in maintaining a certain decorum, atmosphere and legacy of an institute, let’s go back and take a quick lesson about an institution steeped in rich history, namely the Aitchison College. Aitchison College was founded on January 2, 1886, as the Punjab Chief’s college, and was renamed the Aitchison College on November 3, of the same year. The foundation stone of the new building (now known as the old building) was laid down by the Earl of Dufferin and Ava. The college is named after the (then) Lt Governor of Punjab; Sir Charles Umpherston Aitchison. The iconic building of the Aitchison has been a part of the Lahore landscape for more than a century now and represents generations of old boys who take pride in their Alma mater. They reminisce nostalgically about the buggy rides, the hockey and polo fields, the swimming pool, the houses and the turbans. Admission at Aitchison College sends all of Lahore, if not all of Punjab, in an educational frenzy (similar to what Karachi Grammar School does in Karachi). This year was no different (at least initially), the tests were conducted over a period of three days (how a five to six-year-old can take on this kind of task, that takes a lot of endurance, concentration and dedication, is another debate altogether ). Just before the results were about to be announced, the school issued a notification abolishing all ties of kinship. And this sent many an old boy up in arms. As if that wasn’t enough, when the result came out instead of the usual 120 boys only 70 odd boys were admitted in K2 (it is equivalent to grade two elsewhere in Pakistan and is also the year day boys are admitted in the school) the preceding year in K1 (equivalent to grade one) the boarders are admitted. It did not stop there, for the first time in the history of Aitchison College, the admission list was posted not in the alphabetical order but in the order of the marks scored. What was more was that the names of the 300+ unsuccessful candidates along with their marks were also posted online. This practice I feel is, if nothing else, inhumane. If all candidates were sent letters of acceptance and rejection, the scores could have been communicated privately. Now to tackle the issue that is creating uproar in the educational circles these days; whether kinship should have an impact to swing the admissions? Well, all over the world kinship has played an integral part in elitist institutions: be it Eton or Harrow in the UK, Phillips Andover Academy, the Hotchkiss School in the USA or the Doon International School in India, or for that matter Karachi Grammar School and Aitchison College in Pakistan; all have a history steeped deep in tradition. The old boys (in some cases old girls) play a big part in carrying that legacy and passing it down to the subsequent generations. The alumni from these old institutions are generally close knit and well connected with each other and the Alma Mater (especially when there was no Facebook, LinkedIn or for that matter good old email). So saying that ties of kinship can be abolished completely is like saying that you will break the spine of an institution or sever the jugular vein. But, by saying that it by no way means that no new blood should come in or that every old boy (or girl) is entitled to walk into their Alma Mater and claim a seat for their ward, or in some cases their siblings, nieces  or nephews. I do not believe in pulling strings, calling favours and throwing ones weight to get a non-deserving candidate admitted. Aitchison College, as compared to Karachi Grammar School, gives more importance to the ties of kinship (or at least used to). Schools have seen many successful candidates who go on to excel in their respective fields, so what is it that makes them different and yet similar in some regards? I feel both do a great job of screening students and their parents, to admit those who they feel will, over everything else, preserve the legacy of the school; be it through their fierce loyalty to their houses, their participation in sporting events, debates, founders and speech days, their academics and most importantly preserving the sanctity of their uniforms. Not only the students, but I know for a fact, the parent body takes pride in their ward’s school and preserving its traditions. To sum it all up, I would say that merit above all should play an integral part in the admissions in any educational institute; if an old boy’s (or old girl’s) ward score the same as someone not previously associated with the school, the former should get preference. Trust me, by this you will not get just the Noon’s, the Khosa’s, the Bugio’s, the Bhutto’s but also the Siddiqui’s, the Ahmed’s and an occasional Mirza as well.


If A’ level schools from Karachi were houses from Game of Thrones

$
0
0

I am sure that anyone who has seen the Game of Thrones would love to know what house they would belong to had they been part of the series. But what if we lived in a world where houses were based on the A’ level colleges that people attended – or were aspiring to attend? How would that work? After a lot of research and analytical conversations with alumni from the top ten A’ level institutes in Karachi, I was able to grasp a sound, albeit limited, understanding of the kind of students who studied at these particular schools. And in GOT language, this is how the schools can be best understood: 1) Karachi Grammar School (KGS) – House Lannister Mostly rich, these kids have an air of superiority that surrounds them. The similarities between KGS folks and the Lannisters are uncanny! [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="245"]game of thrones animated GIF Photo: Giphy[/caption] 2) The Lyceum – House Stark Everyone’s favourite, and ruled the A’ level realm once upon a time. But they have fallen now and are too scattered to find their bearing. Also, they believe in diversity. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="245"]game of thrones animated GIF Photo: Giphy[/caption] 3) Nixor College – House Targaryen The school, like Daenerys Stormborn aka Khaleesi, came to the surface a few years ago and is now making its way to take over the kingdoms. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="500"]Game of Thrones animated GIF Photo: Giphy[/caption] 4) Beaconhouse Schooling System – House Baratheon While they are part of the elite schools (houses), there is lack of unity within them as there are many branches (brothers) and they often end up competing with each other. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="389"]slapping animated GIF Photo: Giphy[/caption] 5) Bay View High School – House Tyrell Their presence or absence doesn’t make a difference. They tend to aim high and become rulers of the realm, even if that means leaving your school (name) and getting admission (marrying) into another. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="245"]game of thrones animated GIF Photo: Giphy[/caption] 6) City School PAF Chapter – House Tully While their individuals end up making a name for themselves (hint: Catelyn), they are not a very prominent school (house) collectively. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="245"]george rr martin game of thrones gif Photo: Wifflegif[/caption] 7) St Patrick’s High School – House Bolton They are aggressive and would not hesitate in cutting others down if it leads to their victory. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="500"]game of thrones animated GIF Photo: Giphy[/caption] 8) South Shore School for A-level Studies – House Greyjoy They are close to the sea. Their members have a habit of partying and having a good time, even if it means they’ll get into trouble for that. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="500"] Photo: Tumblr[/caption] 9) Foundation Public School – House Frey While they don’t have any major role in the realm, they are often visited when there is nowhere else to go. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="245"]game of thrones animated GIF Photo: Giphy[/caption] 10) The Avicenna School – House Tarth The members are helpful and loyal to their school (name) but nobody really cares about them and often other houses make fun of them. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="245"] Photo: Tumblr[/caption] Bonus: Private candidates – The commoners Those who see these great houses fight and brawl against each other while they go on their merry (or morose) way. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="500"] Source: Uproxx.com[/caption] Yours truly belongs to this category.


Here is why I think CAS is the best school in Pakistan

$
0
0

After spending nine years and counting at Centre of Advance Studies (CAS), I have come to cherish and value the teachings and experiences it has given me. The corn stand’s lala and the cafeteria staff has become the outlet of our daily ramblings. In every Centarian’s life, there are very few experiences that can compete with singing our school song, fighting for the last paratha roll and sitting by the steps waiting to high-five every junior that walks by.

“Imagination is more important than knowledge” – Albert Einstein
This teaching is what highlights the CAS amid many other nation-wide recognised schools. While other educational institutes are driven by the thirst for grades and narrowly defined academic achievements, CAS teaches skills and expertise that are applicable outside the classroom. CAS bridges the gap between what is being taught in schools and the issues students have to address in the real world, outside the cocoon of parents and teachers. The piled burden of mathematic calculations, historic accounts and scientific theories are one half of CAS’s curriculum. The other half focuses on discovering hidden talents and potential successes that are not necessarily academic in nature. Music, art and drama facilities have been provided to students with frequent developments. While CAS may not have the best sports facilities on campus as compared to other schools such as KGS (Karachi Grammar School), Aitchison College and Bay View Academy, it has arranged for students to engage in rowing, golf, tennis and squash at Karachi Boat Club, DHA Golf Club, DA Creek Club and Moin Khan Academy, respectively. At CAS, the development of the intellectual and physical self is balanced by involvement in community concerns and developing a social conscience. While CAS recognises and instils its students to take pride in their triumphs, as a Centarian, I was also taught to be humble and modest. Students’ accomplishments are appreciated and applauded, creating a sense of belonging and comfort for the students, consequently encouraging them to surpass their own, and the teachers’ expectations. Centarians are taught to be confident and graceful with respect for peers, which outshines most teachings that any textbook has to offer. Even though many other schools produce well-rounded, composed and respectful individuals, CAS also teaches them to be confident within themselves. CAS takes most pride in its diverse array of students. There is representation from multiple ethnic, social and religious communities, all of which work in harmony to create an integrated, gallant, and supportive student body. Such boundaries are not present in any circle of friends. While strolling through the ground, there won’t be any group perfect for the typical stereotypes present in other schools. Loyalty, unanimity and courtesy are the three fundamentals taught to each Centarian, as soon as they enter CAS. Any sense of superiority is condemned within the school, as all students stand shoulder to shoulder, regardless of their social and cultural background or beliefs. A student government is formed from the students of Grade 11, the senior most, who don’t only represent their grade, but the entire school and each and every student. Elections are conducted, which are considered one of the festivities of our school. We vote, help campaign, rally for our friends, and respect even those who do not get the black gown. Some may argue that their institute is superior to CAS but they cannot compete with the personal relationship established between the students and the faculty. Although these institutes have a better infrastructure, and perhaps more enhanced facilities provided on campus, CAS’s affable environment sets students at ease to interact with teachers, whether it be academic related or not. After a while, the school becomes a second home, not just an institute. Speaking from personal experience, my third grade teacher is one of the many teachers that I can turn to for advice and assistance at any stage of my academic or personal decisions. Seven years later, and she still remains the first teacher I refer to in times of perplexity. The relationship between teachers and students is further strengthened with the school’s various student exchange programs, in which teachers accompany a few group of students to different countries such as India, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka to explore their culture and traditions, as well as share our own. Along with the student exchange trips, each year, Grade 10 is sent to Lahore on a five-day study trip, in which the students get an opportunity to develop an interest in their nation’s history and create a bond with their peers. The trip exposes us to a variety of social and cultural traditions of Pakistan, but the memories made with our friends and teachers are those that cannot be forgotten. The sleeping picture collages, selfies with teachers, and sharing of shairi have created a unique place in our hearts, which have been possible only because of CAS. The school’s philosophy and motto may not always produce the best academic outcomes, but it does develop a versatile, self-reliant and persistent individual. Centarians are ambitious, with a raging desire and willingness to excel in whatever one does. Seemingly, the opposite of being ambitious, humility sits in elegant balance within the students. While other schools’ formal education, firm rules and restrictions stifle the creativity of pupils, CAS’s academics are such that they are able to exude their creativity in their own manner. The epitome of a true Centarian is Ms Farhat Rasheed, who has accomplished a lot in the years after CAS. She is the president of Show You Care, an advocacy group for the physically disabled. One of my most cherished memories in this school is the second grade sports day as the Yellow House Captain. Reminiscing over it still gives me a nostalgic feeling. I distinctly remember proudly marching down the tracks of National Cricket Stadium, holding the yellow house flag and scanning the stadium bleachers for my parents. I had to control the urge to wave to them elatedly. At that time, I thought that the feeling of pride that had enveloped me was the result of being captain of my house team, but later on I realised it was because of being a Centarian and being a part of a community of excellence. Each day that I walk down the school halls, a warm feeling dissolves in the depths of my heart and I feel proud of CAS, its teachings, and the opportunities it has provided for us.

Remembering Benazir Bhutto: This is the last chance we have to save our country

$
0
0

In the Oscar winning 1976 film Network, an ageing anchor-man tells his viewers to go to their windows and scream: “I’m mad as hell, and I’m not going to take it any more”. The tragic, completely unnecessary death of Benazir Bhutto makes me want to do something of the sort. I remember her as a charming, attractive young woman when she came to Karachi Grammar School to do her A’ levels. I was two years behind her with her brother, Murtaza Bhutto, who was more commonly known among his friends as “Mir”. Their younger sister, Sanam Bhutto was with my sister, Samira, at the Convent. Sanam was very close to Samira and a frequent visitor to our house in Bath Island. I cannot say I was one of Mir’s closest friends, but I liked him very much, and remember on occasion being invited to 70 Clifton for his birthdays. There was something about the Bhutto children that made them truly exceptional. It was not their intelligence, or their good looks, or their wealth, all of which they had in abundance. Their father, during this period, was a man to be reckoned with. He was a former foreign minister busy in building the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP). Yet his children had no airs at all. They were down to earth, humble, kind, well mannered, sympathetic and generous. To me, even then, young as I was, this was an immediately appealing quality. During our studies, Mr Bhutto was elected prime minister. Mir and Sanam were moved to Islamabad and Benazir went off to Harvard. It was the last time I was to see Mir. Even though our paths did cross a few years later when he was at Harvard and I was at Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). Both universities are in Cambridge, Massachusetts. All that separates them is a short bus ride. Many times I thought I should call Mir and try to get together. Several years had passed since I knew him in Grammar School. And I was restrained by the feeling that he might think I wanted to see him now that he was the son of the prime minister. I should have known better. Mir was no ordinary son of any prime minister. He was a gem. The first time that I met Benazir after the Grammar School days was by coincidence when we were seated together on a flight from Karachi to Islamabad. These were the days after her first return from exile. She was busy trying to rally her party. We were given ‘bulkhead’ seats in economy class. She did not remember me but seemed to recall my name. When she realised I had been with Mir at school, she was delighted. We talked about mutual friends. I asked her about Mir – he was in exile in Damascus at the time. She said he was well and she was hoping that he would be back soon. She was interested to know what I was doing. It was a short flight. I did not see her again. And never will. I have felt a deep and personal loss at her passing. This was a wonderful, intelligent, vibrant woman whose life was thoughtlessly and frivolously wasted. And it is not just the man who pulled the trigger or the fuse who killed her. It is all of us; you and me – for continuing to put up with the state of affairs as they are. This madness must end. And it can end. But achieving this will take a fundamental change in the thinking that has dominated our government’s policy since the events of September 11, 2001. That is where our problems begin. And that is where one must return to understand where we are, and hence, to chart a course to where we must go. The immediate question that came into everyone’s mind after the events of that day was: Why? Why would 19 educated, young Arab men, with ostensibly bright futures, want to sacrifice their lives? This was a natural question. And many American commentators and analysts initially sought to know the answer. But then, suddenly, the question was disallowed, on the spurious ground that posing it was tantamount to justifying terrorism. This warped logic was then wrapped in the fervour of patriotism. So it was suddenly un-American to even ask! This was a tragedy of its own. Had the question been allowed, the American people would have learned that the 9/11 attacks were in fact a direct consequence of their government’s policy in the Middle East. It was the consequence of (the still) simmering Arab anger over America’s seemingly blind support for Israeli repression of the Palestinians. Had the question been allowed, the American people would have realised that the appropriate response would have been to have a balanced foreign policy in the Middle East. Humanity would have been spared the continuing tragedy it faces today in Iraq, Afghanistan and across the Muslim and Arab world. Tens of thousands of Muslims and several thousand young American men and women would still be alive. And, yes, had the question been asked, Benazir may still be alive. Why the American establishment chose to disallow the question is not our concern. It is best left to historians and anthropologists. What is our concern is the impact this fateful decision had on Pakistan. America was at war with terror. This was a disembodied phantom whose habitat was thought to be the Near and Middle East. Its acolytes were bearded, hirsute and turbaned Muslims. They exuded hate for the western way of life. They would get America if America didn’t get them. And so the strategy was to get them first. When Pakistan signed up to be an ally, this mind-set was transposed unaltered to the Pakistani establishment. This was to have tragic consequences for all Pakistanis. The ‘enemy’ had been defined so broadly that perhaps more than half of the male population of Pakistan could, by this definition, be deemed ‘terrorists’. This did not matter to America. These ‘terrorists’ did not live in Texas. They lived in the Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa (K-P). The Pakistani army was sent in to kill and capture them. These hapless troops had the almost impossible task of distinguishing friend from foe. Who was a terrorist? And who was just a simple, bearded, gun toting Pakhtun going about his everyday business? What seemed to have escaped the Pakistani establishment was that the overwhelming majority of Pakistanis are deeply conservative people. This is especially true of the provinces that are contiguous with Afghanistan. These are fiercely conservative tribal people who have lived their lives in this way for centuries. They were already angry about the forced ‘modernisation’ and the battle against ‘obscurantism’ that seemed to have become government policy since 2001. Who was the government to tell them how to live their lives? Who was the government to beam dozens of satellite channels into their ultra conservative homes with (to them) scandalously unacceptable content under the guise of modernity and enlightenment? Who was the government to tell their women to remove their veils and uncover their heads? So when the army moved in they – and perhaps the majority of Pakistanis – had already had enough. If you are a stranger in the K-P and say ‘Salaam’ to a Pakhtun, he welcomes you as an honoured guest and will lay down his life to protect yours. Cross him, though, and you have made a mortal enemy. So what do you expect when the army moves in with helicopter gunships, and unmanned, unseen aircraft rain death and destruction on these people and their loved ones? The government is at war with its own people. And this particular group of people is willing to fight to the end, and will strike with whatever means it has at its disposal. This is a clearly disproportionate battle. The army has to find legitimate targets. The ‘enemy’ can sink into any part of the country, attack an infinitude of ‘targets’ and disappear into thin air. It is a battle the army cannot win. This is where we stand today: Suicide bombs, sabotage of critical infrastructure, attacks on military convoys and targets, assassinations.  Am I justifying terrorism? I don’t know. All I know is that this is the truth. So what is to be done? To start with we have to realise that these are our people. They are Pakistanis and they have a right to live on this land in the manner in which they have always lived. We cannot say to them: You hate us, you are terrorists, we will not talk to you, we will just kill you. This is the government’s strategy. It is not working. No one hates without reason. We have to understand their position. This can only happen by talking to them. Is it not time for all of us to start talking and stop fighting? Has not enough blood been shed? Has Pakistan not been brought to its knees by this needless internecine conflict? Let’s be clear: this is the last chance we have to save our country. And, finally, if we are successful, what a wonderful tribute that would be to that charming, intelligent young woman who sat next to me on a flight to Islamabad on a clear winter morning two decades ago. Let us make sure – all of us – that her death was not in vain.


Do you qualify? The imperialistic exclusivity of the Karachi Grammar School

$
0
0

Like many Karachiites who get very good results in their ‘O’ levels, I decided that my grades were my ticket to the prestigious Karachi Grammar School (KGS). KGS, you see, practises a vague semblance of meritocracy (and maintains its college admission rate records) by allowing a handful of high-achievers into their hallowed gates at the A-level stage. People nod impressively if you tell them you went to KGS, and in a city obsessed with class and nepotism, the doors of KGS mean opportunity and exclusivity. In short, the school represented to me an elusive and exclusive glamour that I wanted to experience, first hand. I spent most of my childhood and teenage years in a middle-class school in Karachi; my friends were children of businessmen and dentists, but also drivers and office clerks. My best friend worked in a shop on weekends and the vast majority of us had not been outside Pakistan. It wasn’t a great school – some of the teachers were lax and the discipline severe – but I had a firm group of friends with whom I grew up, sharing the usual secrets and fantasies, angst and concerns. I read constantly, and liked to write stories. I had a special bond with my English teacher and a safe, supportive home environment. Maybe that all contributed to why everyone was proud but nobody particularly surprised that I did well at school. Somewhat surprisingly, my parents didn’t love the idea of my going to KGS. Or at least my mother didn’t. She thought I would become spoiled and start speaking in that distinctive American-twanged Grammarian accent and that my academic talents would perish. She felt, very strongly, that I should follow my older siblings into a good A-level institution that didn’t reek of elitism and ostentation. But I fought back tooth and nail until she gave in. She flipped, as many good parents do when they realise that their children’s minds are made up, from fervent opposition to unconditional support and accompanied me when I went to hand in the application form. Any ‘New G’ (someone who starts at KGS at A-level stage) knows that the OG (old Grammarian)/New G divide is a vast abyss. ‘You’re not the same,’ the OG’s inform you pretty much from day one, in those overt words and also in deed. The New G’s, mired in shame at this rejection, try desperately to fit in. The girls’ uniforms get tighter and shorter until they look like their OG peers’. Accents change subtly and anyone going on a trip abroad is desperately propositioned to bring schoolbags, sweaters and shoes from London or New York. I was not immune, not even a little bit. I quickly abandoned my old friends, the middle-class, unfashionable girls that I had grown up with. I cautioned my parents to speak in English whenever my new ‘friends’ were around. I scrutinised my whole life differently – why did my mother not wear glamorous clothes and jewellery like my class-mates’ mums? Why did we not have expensive paintings in our house? And why didn’t we ‘holiday’ in Spain or Italy like other people did? I grew shameful of things I had no need to be shameful of, and prided in other things that were pure form over substance. I suppose you could say I lost myself, a little bit. I remember a school fellow saying to us jokingly on day one,

‘You must be so excited to be here. People bow down, you know, when you tell them you go to KGS.’
It seemed to me a toxic way to conceive of yourself as a child and also, an unwarm welcome that asserts hierarchy. On some level, I had it easier than others – my light skin and slim body conformed to the standards of beauty at my new school, which followed an imperialist, white supremacist aesthetic so strongly that I’m sure, if a time-traveller were to land inside the high-walled campus one day, it wouldn’t take much to convince them that they were still in colonial times. Value was based, without a doubt, on proximity to westernisation. If you were fair skinned (ideally, with a white or non-desi parent), you were automatically more desirable. An accent that signified frequent visits abroad added further value. The lighter the hair, the less dark the eyes, the more attractive you were considered. Speaking Urdu well was undesirable – this was a language reserved for speaking to servants in. The teachers spoke in clipped anglicised accents and made clear that the epitome of progress would be if one went on to Harvard or Yale, Oxford or Cambridge. Urdu was taught only as a second language and the admissions process, with the exception of the A-level loophole, involved requests for proof that parents or siblings went there in the past. There were headboys and headgirls, and school houses called things like Napier and Papworth, named after the colonial masters who founded the school – KGS, established in the mid 1800s, was the first school in the city for ‘non-natives’. It could be argued that the Karachi Grammar School has much to be proud of – its alumni include renowned political figures, Oscar-winning film-makers and some very good journalists. The fact that these people had access to resources (including each other) that made their position possible in the first place probably has more to do with their success than the school’s actual influence, but, like most elite institutions, this access to networks and resources is a large part of where the school’s appeal lies. KGS went through massive changes in its pre-colonial days including name changes from ‘The Anglo-Indian School’ in 1847 to ‘The Kurrachee European and Indo-European School’ in 1854 to the Karachi Grammar School in 1879. It has remained more or less in this state since, moving from serving the children of European colonisers to their neo-colonial inheritors, retaining the strict class barriers and ridiculously anachronistic and elitist traditions, producing achievements celebrated by Western establishment figures and local elite alike. However, room for difference or radicalism, innovation and activism, is left closed. Any generosity stems from ego, patronisation and pity, not real empathy or compassion. The output of this school may have polish and confidence, but it is also somewhat cookie-cutter, establishment, conservative, and out-of-touch. The bubble of KGS can stretch only so wide – many of its alumni end up marrying each other, sending their children to KGS, and finding solace in an ethos that is fervently anti-‘fundo’ and pro-capitalist, one that involves lavish parties and frequent travel – this is the KGS ethos to dealing with the chaos that is Karachi. And perhaps there is also great profundity or happiness inside this bubble. The truth is, I wouldn’t know for sure. But I feel that a massive decolonisation is needed within those gated campuses, one that questions the cliquish imperialist assumptions on which its foundation stands. And more importantly still, a decolonisation must take place within us that allows us to see those imperialistic standards for what they are and that allows us to question the worth of this over-esteemed institution. Do I wish I had never gone to that school? Saved myself two years of snobbery and condescension, and feelings of low self-worth that can be very harmful when you’re in your teens? That I’d seen my mother as a source of wisdom, not antagonism and old-fashionedness and listened to her more carefully? Not really. That struggle probably helped me develop the critical skills that allow me to see the world in the way I do now. Still, I believe that snobbery and elitism and the enforcement of strict class difference create wounds that run so deep that we can barely look at them. And that’s why we must. There was no question of solidarity amongst the New G’s. On the contrary, we tried our hardest to distance ourselves from each other, as this increased the chances of being absorbed into the OG networks. But this also left people on the side-lines, isolated and confused. To acknowledge that the problem was to do with class or background was almost more embarrassing than just believing that there was something in your character that didn’t quite fit. To be confronted with hostility or exclusion, whatever the reason, is always painful. But it is also usually unwarranted. And it is strengthening. [poll id="521"]

KGS isn’t perfect but it isn’t quite as bad as you may think either

$
0
0

To some, Karachi Grammar School (KGS) is a name as synonymous with snobby elitism as it is with academic prestige to others. On the one hand, those enrolled in the school make us proud with an impressive list of notable alumni and achievements, in both national and international competitions. The same students also warrant spite for their reputation of being overly westernised, entitled and completely out of touch with the society in which they live. But the question is, how did it get to this? To understand that, we have to go back to colonial India in 1847, when the school was first established as the Anglo-Indian School by a Reverend Henry Brereton. Naturally, at the time the school would have catered to the children of British officials rather than those of the local populace, as was the case with many colonial institutions at the time. The way I see it, this could very easily be the start of the stereotype that still holds today. Coming back to present day Karachi, the city has evolved significantly and is now home to over 10 million people. Karachi Grammar School still has not managed to shake off the identity of a colonial institution, except instead of catering to the foreign elite it caters to the (much worse) local elite. KGS is a school for those vain, wealthy few with a superiority complex matched by none, it’s a place where they’re among others like themselves, meaning others who too are too good for the rabble that surrounds them and are never really seen outside of a particular social circle, a particular part of town or a particular setting that just reeks of decadence. At least, that’s what it is to the outside observer. I myself have been studying at KGS for about 12 years now, so I daresay I know what I’m talking about. I’ll be the first to admit, the school is not perfect. However it isn’t quite as bad as most people seem to think it is. It is also true that we, unfortunately, have people who fit the above description. But that doesn’t mean that they’re the only ones, or that they constitute a large enough portion of the 2400 students to define us as a whole. And granted that some among us are, through no fault of their own, not quite in touch with their culture and language; considering it is not focused on as much as English is. And yes, the houses are named after British officers (something I personally, among others, have protested for some time now). Yes, you’re also correct to acknowledge that it isn’t easy to gain admission. But, despite all that, the school and the student body have definitely been taking steps in the right direction. Using my own experience as an example, I’ve taken to speaking to my friends in Urdu, and have heard a fair amount of others doing the same. I’ve also noticed that, within a month or so, newly admitted students fit in just fine, irrespective of what background they came from. This year, some of the new additions to my group of friends had previously attended public schools but still get the same treatment that the rest of us do. I’ve also seen new students fitting in with the grade and into the school better than I ever have, primarily because I’m not a very social person. On multiple occasions, whenever I meet people from other schools (in my case it’s usually at an MUN) they automatically assume I’m obsessed with winning or that I’m generally unpleasant and unapproachable. On one occasion, someone told me they couldn’t believe I was from KGS because I was “too nice”. And this isn’t a one-time thing either; even my team members have had similar experiences. It is interesting to see that a stereotype that is almost two centuries old continues to exist. But, what’s even more interesting is that the snob stigma specifically applies to our school, even though there are many schools similar to ours. Maybe because it hits so close to home, it feels that way. Overall, I’ll be the first to admit, we have a long way to go, but despite that, I’d like to be the first to defend the school for the progress it has made. After all, there is no such thing as a perfect system but still, we at the school are trying nonetheless. [poll id="529"]



KGS, FPS, Nixor, Southshore, Lyceum or Cedar – The choices you make today will mould your future tomorrow

$
0
0

If you think you can relax right after taking your O’ level examinations, you’re wrong. Right after you’re done with your exams, people begin bombarding you with all sorts of questions, asking you what your plans are for college and what subjects you’re going to opt for. There is literally no chill, and apparently for all the right reasons. The decisions you make now will affect the course of your life. I know this sounds scary, but it’s true. After O’ level exams finish, the main concern is the arduous process of choosing a school for A’ levels. But before getting to that part, you have to decide whether you are going to do A’ levels or intermediate. Many of your relatives will advise you to go for intermediate as it means that you are more likely to get admission into an engineering programme or a medical college They will probably tell you how much easier it will be for you to get a job in your country. However, it is entirely up to you. If you do not want to become an engineer or doctor, then perhaps opting for A’ levels will be a more practical choice. Nonetheless, while choosing a school for your further studies, you must remember that the school you opt for will play a big part in your life ahead; not only in picking a university, but in your career and more importantly, in shaping your personality. After deciding whether you will be going for intermediate or A’ levels, you have the task of deciding which school you are going to study in. There are various factors to consider. For starters, you must be able to afford the school. However, you shouldn’t be obsessed with the cost, as many schools offer scholarships and if you study hard enough, you can earn the scholarships. Other than that, this is the era of independence, where you can start earning your own money and partially pay for your tuition fee. It is preferable for the school to be close to your residence so you don’t have to worry about traffic or getting late every morning. When it comes to Karachi, a school in Defence wouldn’t be desirable if you’re living in North Nazimabad. However, sometimes even the nearest school may end up very far, and in that case, you should have plans in place, such as waking up early or studying during the ride to school. You should also take into account the faculty, and particularly, the teachers of the subjects you will be opting for. Good teachers will make sure that you get the best out of school and that you do not feel the need to take tuitions for any given subject. Visit the school before deciding, and have a look around to make sure that whatever you’ve heard or read about it is true. Various colleges offer personal tours of the campus so you can use that to erase any doubts from your mind. You must be careful about a few aspects such as not choosing a certain school simply because your friend is not planning on applying there, or because someone told you that it’s highly reputable. It is imperative that one finds out about the school themselves, reviews all of their options and after carefully considering each one, decides which one they’re going to apply to instead of making a haste decision. You must not choose a school because your parents advise you to do so, learn to make your own choices. In some cases, people turn down offers from great schools simply because an ‘enemy’ of theirs is enrolled in that school which is very foolish of them to do. While choosing, you will find that there are some colleges that are famous for just partying and having fun, and not studying, while others have good reputations for their studies and faculty. You have to keep in mind that you’re attending school to study, and have a little fun alongside, and not just to have fun. It is good to be focused on a single goal and to work hard to achieve it. But sometimes you are unable to achieve that particular goal, and under these conditions, it is helpful to have a ‘Plan B’. Similarly, while applying for colleges, it is better if you keep your options open and apply to as many colleges as you can, rather than just applying to the one you want to get into. This way, if you don’t get admission into college A, you can always consider colleges B, C or D. In Karachi, three of the most prestigious colleges are Nixor CollegeLyceum School and Karachi Grammar School (KGS). KGS is said to be the best school in Karachi and it has the highest standards of entry so you’ll be in the company of the best people. It is the oldest school offering A’ levels, so with this school comes years of experienced staff. However, it has old-aged faculty which may cause communication gaps between the teachers and their students. Lyceum is said to be the ideal college for students with commerce subjects, and it has some of the best faculty in town along with some amazing extracurricular activities. Nixor also has some of the best teachers in town and is now making a name for itself. It has notable extracurricular activities as well. Another option could be the newly opened Cedar CollegeSouthshore School for A’Levels or even Bay View High School. There are so many options out there; you just have to find the one that suits you best. However, I myself am planning to go to Foundation Public School’s (FPS) A’ level campus because I have been with FPS since nursery and now after 11 years, it feels like my second home and I have a strong connection with it. Other than that, the faculty is pretty good too and I won’t have to pay the admission fee since I am an FPSonian. Good luck to those applying!


With Zidane back on the sidelines, will Real Madrid make the most of the summer transfer window?

$
0
0
For much of the 2018-19 season, Real Madrid’s campaign has been driven by pessimism and trepidation. From mediocre performances on the field to a lack of purpose off it, the Los Blancos found themselves entrenched in a diatribe with a swathe of negative opinions from fans and critics alike.  But the return of the clubs’s favourite son Zinedine Zidane after his dignified exit nine months ago has cut through all the noise, at least for the time being. Zizou’s work is cut out for him as the rebuilding job at a club like Real Madrid, with extremely high expectations, won’t be an easy task by any stretch of the imagination. https://twitter.com/kevinchimuka/status/1113392173150502914 However, unlike towards the end of his last tenure, Zidane will have financial backing from the club. A report from The Independent claimed “Real Madrid president Florentino Perez has promised Zidane an expensive overhaul,” immediately after the Frenchman’s arrival. A few days later L’Equipe’s front page (titled Casino Royal) stated that: “Perez is ready to show faith in Zidane to turn the ship around by giving him a €500 million summer budget.” If Madrid are keen on spending heavily in the upcoming summer transfer window, they will have to do it wisely, bearing in mind their current expectations and without compromising future ambitions. Defence Real Madrid’s defence is, arguably, the least concerning aspect of their squad. Sergio Ramos and Raphael Varane might not have had the best of seasons, but they still form a formidable pairing in the centre of defence. But with Ramos aging and especially if Varane decides to leave, Madrid would need adequate replacements in order to beef up their backline options. Looking at the options, three names stand out in particular. These include Napoli’s Kalidou Koulibaly (27), Inter Milan’s Milan Skriniar (24) and Ajax’s Matthijs de Ligt (19). [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="600"] Kalidou Koulibaly during the Serie A match between US Sassuolo and SSC Napoli at Mapei Stadium - Citta' del Tricolore on March 10, 2019 in Reggio nell'Emilia, Italy. Photo: Getty[/caption] All three have no obvious weaknesses and possess the ideal skill set expected from a defender (strength, positioning and ball playing skills), supplemented by the fact that they are young enough to be part of the club for a very long time. While Madrid would be happy to bring in any one of these players, Skriniar would be cheaper as compared to the other two, considering the absence of a release clause in his contract with Inter. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="600"] Milan Skriniar of FC Internazionale competes for the ball with Danny da Costa of Eintracht Frankfurt during the UEFA Europa League Round of 16 Second Leg match between FC Internazionale and Eintracht Frankfurt at San Siro on March 14, 2019 in Milan, Italy. Photo: Getty[/caption] The 24-year-old also offers an added dimension of having played as a defensive midfielder with the Slovakian national side, and consequently can provide cover on two positions while also aiding in-game tactical switch. Midfielders Real Madrid have a substantial amount of talent in the centre of the park, with an impressive blend of young (Marcos Llorente, Fede Valverde and Dani Ceballos) and experienced players (Luka Modric, Toni Kroos and Casemiro). In order to cater to an aging Modric and take off pressure from Kroos, Madrid need a couple of additions to their midfield. However, they don’t need to spend heavily in this regard as the players they have loaned out – James Rodriguez to Bayern Munich and Mateo Kovacic to Chelsea – will be ideal suitors. Rodriguez’s incisiveness in the final third, both in open play and dead ball situations, will add creativity in central positions. This is of particular importance because a majority of Madrid’s attacks are wing-based, which is why the Colombian’s presence will stretch opposing defences and bring more unpredictability going forward. Also, through his quotes in the press, the midfielder has also indicated that there is no love lost between him and the Spanish giants, despite being left frustrated for playing time under Zidane previously. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="600"] James Rodriguez of FC Bayern Muenchen controls the ball during the Bundesliga match between FC Bayern Muenchen and 1. FSV Mainz 05 at Allianz Arena on March 17, 2019 in Munich, Germany. Photo: Getty[/caption] Kovacic might not have had the best of seasons at Chelsea, but he can still play a vital role in The Whites midfield with his ability to play line-breaking passes; a trait which is of pivotal importance, especially against many La Liga sides who like to sit deep and defend. Also, the Croatian’s best time in Madrid colours came while playing under Zizou, which makes a strong case of having him back in the Spanish capital. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="600"] Mateo Kovacic of Chelsea in action during the FA Cup Fifth Round match between Chelsea and Manchester United at Stamford Bridge on February 18, 2019 in London, United Kingdom. Photo: Getty[/caption] Forwards Ever since the departure of club legend Cristiano Ronaldo, the talk surrounding Real Madrid’s attacking pedigree has shown no signs of subsiding. Since the departure of the Portuguese, the goals have significantly dried up for the Los Blancos and hence the need for some clinical finishers in front of the goal is, probably, more than ever. Talking about forwards, one player that has constantly been linked with Real Madrid is Chelsea’s Eden Hazard. Although there is no doubt about the Belgium international’s footballing prowess and he will also be a seamless fit at Real, signing him now, at the age of 28, would mean the club shelling a lot of money in return for only two to three peak years. While it would be unfair to totally rule out a move, the club should only consider Hazard as a fall-back option. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="600"] 31st March 2019, Cardiff City Stadium, Cardiff, Wales; EPL Premier League football, Cardiff City versus Chelsea; Eden Hazard of Chelsea looks back at a missed chance. Photo: Getty[/caption] Moving on, Paris Saint-Germain’s (PSG) Kylian Mbappe, despite being an ideal solution to Real Madrid’s goal scoring troubles, is a long shot considering his massive price tag. Although there are plenty of rumours in the transfer market regarding his move to Spain, the French club will go all out to keep the 20-year-old star at the club, keeping in mind the fact that he is at the core of their European ambitions. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="600"] Kylian Mbappe of PSG celebrates a goal during the Ligue 1 match between Paris Saint Germain and Guingamp at Parc des Princes on January 19, 2019 in Paris, France. Photo: Getty[/caption] Taking into account all the factors and realistic options available on the market, Real Madrid will be better off if they work on the lines of signing Liverpool’s Sadio Mane and Inter Milan’s Mauro Icardi. Mane’s pace and technical ability has been part and parcel of Liverpool’s success in the past couple of seasons, and he will add a lot of potency to Real Madrid’s attack. Although he has played mostly as a winger for The Reds, if need be, he can play in a more central role as a striker as well. In Mane, Madrid will find a willing worker, who can track back and help out with defence and also link up well with Marcelo Vieira on the left wing. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="600"] Sadio Mane of Liverpool FC runs with the ball during the Premier League match between Liverpool FC and Tottenham Hotspur at Anfield on March 31, 2019 in Liverpool, United Kingdom. Photo: Getty[/caption] On the other hand, Icardi has stacked up some great numbers for his Italian club with his lethal finishing. He may not participate much in build-up play but his positioning and movement in front of the goal is particularly impressive. Real Madrid have been guilty of creating lots of chances but not converting them during the ongoing season, but Icardi’s signing should go a long way in changing that. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="600"] Mauro Icardi of FC Internazionale scores the second goal during the Serie A match betweenGenoa CFC and FC Internazionale at Stadio Luigi Ferraris on April 3, 2019 in Genoa, Italy. Photo: Getty[/caption] To Madrid and Zidane’s advantage, being knocked out of the title race on all fronts is somewhat a blessing in disguise, as it gives them additional time to plan for the future. But the 13-time European Champions will have to be clever with the way they go about their business in the transfer market, before it builds up more scar tissue against their name as a formidable force in the world of football.

Why is the US making a mountain out of the Masood Azhar molehill?

$
0
0
The United States has introduced a United Nations Security Council (UNSC) resolution to blacklist Masood Azhar as an international terrorist. Azhar is the leader of Jaish-e-Mohammed (banned in Pakistan since 2002) and has been blamed by India for masterminding February’s Pulwama incident, even though no evidence has been produced which links Azhar to the incident. China has refused to list Azhar as an international terrorist after careful consideration of the definition of international terrorism according to international law. China has made this position absolutely clear and as such, it would appear that the US is looking to transform the UNSC into a place of high stakes geopolitical theatre, because China’s veto of the US resolution is inevitable. The US therefore is using the internationally immaterial issue of Azhar in order to provoke tensions between China and India at a time when the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) is already invoking blood-curdling Sinophobia in further attempts to rally the jingoist Hindutva vote. But this is not all that the US is doing. Washington is also provoking and in fact insulting Pakistan by suggesting that a local matter is worthy of wasting the UN’s time, even after one of the permanent members of the Security Council has made its position unambiguous. As if on cue, India’s jingoistic media kicked into high gear suggesting war against China. Meanwhile, members of the BJP and the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) continue to call for a boycotting of Chinese goods. When it comes to Pakistan however, America’s willingness to inflate the international importance of Azhar makes it clear that the US is willing to risk productive relations with Pakistan in order to both placate India and to goad India into an even more extreme position vis-a-vis China (not that the BJP needs much help in this respect). Although the US has admitted that Pakistan’s role in the Afghan peace process is crucial, beyond this, the US has clearly made its decision in terms of a long term strategy in South Asia. While some US diplomats will feign attempts at a balanced South Asia policy, the reality is that India is now a key US strategic partner. US diplomats at the UN will happily do India’s bidding, even over a matter as absurd as trying to convince the world that Azhar is an international terrorist when legal precedent says otherwise. Pakistan must adjust its own expectations accordingly. While it would be imprudent for Pakistan to provoke any superpower, the message that Washington is not so subtly sending is that when it comes to a superpower partner, China is the singular key to Pakistan’s prosperous future, while the US is becoming little more than a puppet master helping direct flagrant Indian aggression against China. This is all the more reason for Pakistan to take a more assertive role in the Afghan peace process. As the country most directly affected by Afghanistan’s prolonged status as a failed state, Pakistan has no excuse not to emerge as an international leader in driving forward an all-parties peace process. Any idea that Pakistan should merely shadow the US in respect of the peace process should now be put to rest, as it is clear that the US has India’s strategic desires at heart and that, by comparison, Pakistan’s security needs come a very distant second or even third. The reality Pakistan must now face is that whilst America’s priorities in the South Asia during the 80’s related to containing Afghanistan to the West and the Soviet Union to the North, today the US is squarely focused on provoking China and for this, India will remain a key ally of Washington. All that Pakistan must now do is acclimate itself to a new reality where China’s all-weather friendship will grow in stature and material importance while the US will be willing to insult, debase and ignore Pakistan as though the events of the 80’s never occurred. This post was originally published here. 

Knock knock! Annabelle is coming home and things are about to get real scary

$
0
0
Following the Marvel path, The Conjuring universe has grown steadily over the last six years through both, the increasing returns that most films in the franchise have delivered and in stature through the critical acclaim that the first two Conjuring movies received. Now five movies in, the franchise is showing no signs of slowing down with a third Conjuring film already set for 2020. But before that, we’re getting another Annabelle movie. And this one promises to be much different than its predecessors. [caption id="attachment_81026" align="alignnone" width="600"] Photo: IMDb[/caption] Annabelle Comes Home, which will serve as the sixth film in the Conjuring franchise and the third Annabelle film, does not take the prequel route like Annabelle: Creation did. Unlike the first Annabelle, which was widely panned for being a rudderless and aimless production, this film shifts the focus directly towards the Warren family – the paranormal investigators played by Patrick Wilson and Vera Farmiga who served as the protagonists of the first two Conjuring films. [caption id="attachment_81027" align="alignnone" width="600"] Photo: IMDb[/caption] The first trailer, which came out recently, sprinkles a handful of jump-scares throughout its two and a half minute runtime and the film more or less appears to centre on an artefact room where the Warrens keep the demonic doll. However, soon enough the doll begins turning up in strange places and much to the surprise of the Warrens, so do the other artefacts. The weight of this is felt by the Warren’s 10-year-old daughter, Judy, and her friends who seem to be at the centre of the latest Conjuring film. [caption id="attachment_81024" align="alignnone" width="598"] Photo: IMDb[/caption] By all accounts, Annabelle Comes Home seems like a much more small-scale film as compared to its predecessors which were much more expansive in scope. And though the Warrens are back, they don’t seem to have a central role in the film in the same way as their daughter does. This is promising because it means that perhaps this time the focus will be on a tightly-constructed narrative, which is where horror films work best. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="600"] Photo: Screenshot[/caption] As evidenced by the trailer, it’s perhaps also safe to assume that this film won’t just be about the titular doll but will also focus on some of the other haunted artefacts in the Warren family’s possession which, if anything, may provide the producers with a few more ideas for some future spin-offs. In the context of this film though, it will undoubtedly add to the scares. This is something that producer James Wan has confirmed when he essentially described the film as being Night at the Museum with an evil doll because of the various haunted artefacts that will be activated in the film. [caption id="attachment_81031" align="alignnone" width="600"] Photo: IMDb[/caption] The good thing is that Annabelle Comes Home seems to channel all the elements that have made the Conjuring franchise such a big success, which provides the viewer with something to look forward to. After straying away from the central narrative and focusing on aimless origin stories, the franchise seems to have finally learned its lesson. With Annabelle Comes Home, the focus seems to have been shifted back towards the scares and, in a blatant but smart bit of fan-service, the filmmakers have brought back two of the franchise’s most beloved characters, even if it’s in a supporting capacity. That said, only time will tell if the latest installment in the Annabelle saga matches up to the Conjuring movies, which at present, stand head and shoulders above the other films in the franchise. [caption id="" align="alignnone" width="600"] Photo: Screenshot[/caption] Annabelle Comes Home hits cinemas on June 28, 2019.

India’s ‘Operation Isolation’ and the soft power of sports

$
0
0
“Our message is stronger than ever. Please stop the fighting. Please stop the killing. Please drop your guns.” Juan Antonio Samaranch, President International Olympic Committee speaking at the Winter Olympics, 1994. The sports arena has often been used in modern-day diplomacy to advocate for peace, but it has also been used to aggravate existing conflict. George Orwell wrote in The Sporting Spirit (1945) that sports is “war, minus the shooting” and has the potential to bring out the worst characteristics of nationalism. How that is controlled, or even amplified, is in the hands of those who hold the political controls.  In the days following the Pulwama incident, tensions once again began to escalate between Pakistan and India. While India’s very first reaction was the imposition of a heavy economic sanction, many of the responses which followed came in the form of sports sanctions, primarily impacting something very close to the hearts of people on both sides: cricket. The fourth edition of the Pakistan Super League (PSL) became the primary target of the increasing hostility and vitriol. Prominent Indian-owned media companies and broadcasters, including IMG Reliance, D Sports and CricBuzz, terminated their contracts and coverage of the tournament, leading to a virtual PSL blackout in India. The Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) also came under extraordinary pressure from prominent Indian sporting personalities, media outlets and ordinary citizens, to boycott the upcoming Pakistan-India match at the cricket World Cup (June 2019). https://twitter.com/YusufDFI/status/1097384109200928768 https://twitter.com/MinhazMerchant/status/1099007211689467906 Outside of cricket, other sports have also been effected. It is suggested that Pakistan supplies 90% of the hockey sticks used in India, and would suffer heavily from an increase in customs duty of 200%. As a result, the hockey fraternity in India would have to quickly find new suppliers who could match the demand, as well as replicate the quality from across the border. The Shooting World Cup, which was taking place in New Delhi a week after the attack and was intended to be an Olympic qualifier, also got dragged into the conflict when Pakistani athletes were not granted visas to participate in the tournament. Further economic sanctions would come later, followed by military responses, but it appears that the use of sports sanctions was going to kick start this ‘Operation Isolation’. However, these sanctions did not prove to be effective in isolating Pakistan on the sports field. We saw the PSL replace its distributors almost immediately and have yet another successful edition. Regarding the World Cup, wide coverage of the discussions between the BCCI and the International Cricket Council (ICC) were made public, including copies of the communication between the two bodies. It is clear that the ICC and the organising team of the World Cup do not condone any political battles being played out on the cricket pitch. https://twitter.com/TimesNow/status/1098065107693625344 Perhaps the most surprising stance came from the International Olympic Committee (IOC) in response to Pakistan’s plea regarding the Shooting World Cup. Not only did the IOC revoke the tournament of its Olympic qualification status for the particular discipline, they further went onto suspend all discussions with the Indian government regarding hosting future sporting events in India. The IOC also recommended that all international federations should refrain from hosting any international sporting events in India until written guarantees are provided assuring participation of all athletes. This may prove to be a landmark ruling from the Olympic governing body, which has traditionally not taken such a publicly strong stance on political matters. This is especially true as the initial plea was only to do with the shooting event. However, India is no doubt going to work to revoke this suspension as quickly as possible, even if it means salvaging its ties with Pakistan. Failure to do so could mean that a number of its hosting rights and bids would be up on the chopping block, including the FIFA Under-20 Women’s World Cup (2020), the Hockey World Cup (2022/2023) and ICC Cricket World Cup (2023), among others. https://twitter.com/mehreenzahra/status/1098830460862558208?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1098830460862558208&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fblogsdesk.tribune.com.pk%2Fapplication%2Fwp-admin%2Fpost.php%3Fpost%3D80906%26action%3Dedit This of course is not the first time tensions have escalated between the two neighbours, nor is it the first time that the field of play is used for sanctions to be deployed and political statements to be made. India-Pakistan cricket relations have been turbulent ever since they kicked off in 1952. There have been many positive outcomes where both countries have hosted each other on multiple occasions and opened up their borders for citizens to travel in support of their teams. At the same time, boycotts from governing bodies and protests from ordinary citizens have also had the opposite impact on cricket and other sporting ties between the two nations. The Indian cricket tour to Pakistan (2004) is considered as one of the four most prominent acts of sports diplomacy, with the ‘Christmas Truce’ of World War I (1914), where German and British soldiers were said to have held informal sessions of casual football on Christmas day, being number one. Even outside of the subcontinent, sports have always been a feature of international diplomacy, albeit a more subtle one. We have seen countless protests and boycotts when it comes to international sports, such as the Black Power Salute (at the 1968 Olympics), America’s boycott of the 1980 Olympics during the Cold War,  the Soviet Union’s boycott of the 1984 Olympics, and the international sporting boycott of Apartheid South Africa. However, it would not have been difficult to foresee the potential for sports to have these impacts when the Olympic movement was first initiated. After all, it was developed on the sole idea of using sports to encourage and improve peace among the warring kingdoms in Ancient Greece. The way international sports are conducted and covered today, indicates their potential and ability to bridge gaps between nations. With massive potential to be used as a catalyst in international diplomacy and break barriers, the power of sports can only be as strong as the will and commitment of our global leaders. In an era where hard power is frowned upon by the international community, governments are increasingly inclined to use alternative modes of diplomacy, sports included, to achieve their political goals and shape their international image. If we, the people, can understand the relationship between the two, then we can also influence its impact. This isn’t the first time sports have been used to convey and act upon undertones of conflict and hate, and it unfortunately won’t be the last. For now, we can be aware of how these actions relating to the field of play can be used to condition or influence certain emotions within us, and also pray that our leaders use the pitches and courts to help us come together, rather than to push us apart.
Viewing all 26 articles
Browse latest View live


<script src="https://jsc.adskeeper.com/r/s/rssing.com.1596347.js" async> </script>